I am wondering if Melanie had a botched knee lift. There's no way her legs should look that bad naturally.

Also I think Melanie may have gotten short-changed a bit in the gene pool. If you look at Tippi Hedren's old movies, she has a thin face with very firm skin. Melanie has never had that; Melanie has always had a more fleshy face. At one point in the 1980s, it actually looked quite puffy. Melanie's face actually looks better now than in some of her "puffy" pictures.

Another thing about Lohan, she's a redhead, and may have that extremely sensitive skin that goes along with it. If she insists on baking herself, she may look even worse than Melanie when she hits 40.